OSRS Thieving Guide 1–99: Fastest Methods and Profit

Why Thieving Is Worth 1–99

Thieving is the skill where getting it wrong hits back. A failed pickpocket makes the target damage you and stun you, and the stun is specific: nine ticks in which you cannot move, eight in which you cannot steal, and if you panic-eat inside that window the food's own attack delay is added on top of it. Everything downstream of the skill is shaped by that one rule. Food is not a convenience item here, it is a consumed training input, and the wiki puts the Knights of Ardougne stretch from 55 to 95 at roughly two hundred dodgy necklaces and sixteen thousand hitpoints of healing, with natural regeneration already counted in.

The second thing to understand is that the experience and the money rarely point at the same place. Rogue equipment is the plainest illustration: the full set guarantees double loot from every pickpocket and changes your experience drops not at all. The quickest experience from level 84 sits in a deep Wilderness multicombat zone, beside a chest that turns the surrounding rogues aggressive the moment you open it. Master Farmer seeds and Prifddinas elves, the two names most players associate with stealing for a living, sit behind levels you only reach once the skill has stopped being hard. You will be choosing between those two tracks over and over, and the guide below keeps them separate for that reason.

Third, this is a skill a great deal of other content is waiting on. Thieving requirements run from The Lost Tribe at 13 through to While Guthix Sleeps at 72, and diary tasks in eleven regions ask for it, as high as 91 for the Desert elite tier and 84 for the Wilderness elite. The most consequential of those is circular: the hard Ardougne Diary needs 72 Thieving and then hands back a ten per cent success bonus on pickpocketing every NPC in Gielinor, so the skill's strongest permanent buff arrives about three-quarters of the way through it.

Structurally, Thieving branches into four tracks that barely talk to each other — pickpocketing, stalls, chests, and the timed activities in Sophanem and the Sorceress's Garden. They fail in different ways. A stall theft cannot stun you but can call a guard; a chest can be trapped; a blackjack knockout is a two-tick manual rhythm you either have or do not. A level band that is correct on one track is frequently wrong on the others, which is why a single linear route through this skill has never really existed.

Bils Services offers hand-done Thieving training if you would rather outsource the grind. This article stays educational first — use the service link only if it fits your plan.

We have not put XP per hour or supply costs in this guide. Thieving rates move whenever Jagex adjusts a method, and the cost of the thieving supplies below moves with the Grand Exchange — a frozen number here would mislead you into budgeting the wrong bank. The OSRS Wiki carries live figures.

Quest XP and the Unlocks That Matter

The quest route to 42 is the best-value thing in this guide and it is not quite the free skip it looks like. Tribal Totem in the first batch wants 21 Thieving, and the second batch asks for anything from 20 up to 34, so you are bootstrapping: steal a few levels, cash in a few quests, steal a few more. Some of the early ones involve combat, which is worth knowing before you queue five of them on a fresh account with no gear.

The bigger quest rewards are deliberately not on that list, because they cannot help you early. While Guthix Sleeps pays 80,000 experience but needs 72 Thieving; The Final Dawn pays 55,000 at 66; Dragon Slayer II, Monkey Madness II and Secrets of the North each pay 50,000 and want 60, 55 and 64 respectively. Treat those as windfalls that arrive mid-grind rather than as a plan, and check the wiki's quest reward table before you commit, since reward amounts do get revised.

Two unlocks are worth going out of your way for at awkward moments. The first is The Feud at 30, because a blackjack is not something you can substitute — no other item lets you knock a bandit unconscious, and the whole 45-to-84 fast track is built on doing exactly that. The second is 72 for the hard Ardougne Diary, because its ten per cent applies everywhere and it is what makes Master Farmers and the TzHaar-Hur reasonable later. Note also that the diary perks override the gloves of silence rather than stacking with them, so the diary quietly retires a piece of equipment you may have just bought.

Thieving 1–99 Level Path

The bands overlap heavily and that is not sloppiness, it is the shape of the skill. Pickpocketing, stalls, chests and the timed activities all run from low levels to high ones in parallel, and each one asks for a different thing from you: a stall wants you to watch a line of sight, a chest wants a lockpick and a world-hop, a bandit wants a two-tick rhythm, Pyramid Plunder wants a supply run. Pick a track first and read the table down that track rather than across it.

Two levels are genuine hinges. Forty-five is where blackjacking opens and the skill's ceiling jumps, and it is gated on a quest rather than a level, so it can be brought forward. Eighty-four is where Rogues' Castle opens and the fastest route stops being safe; if you are not going into the Wilderness, your ceiling is Pyramid Plunder at 91 instead, and the seven levels in between are the awkwardest stretch of the whole skill.

The end of Thieving is worth understanding in advance, because it is unusual. With the hard Ardougne Diary complete, each pickpocket target has a level at which you stop failing altogether: 85 for men and women, 90 for farmers, 91 for H.A.M. members, 93 for warriors, 94 for rogues and Master Farmers, 95 for guards, desert bandits and the Knights of Ardougne. Past that point the food, the dodgy necklaces and the stun-avoidance spell all become dead weight, and the same method you have been grinding for twenty levels quietly turns free.

1. 1–5: quest/stall start
2. 5–25: cake stalls / low thievable content
3. 25–45/55: Fruit stalls / blackjack progression (as quests allow)
4. 45–55+: Blackjacking for high XP if you can sustain it
5. 55–99: Knights of Ardougne or other high methods; pyramid plunder for variety/XP

Fastest XP Methods

The fast route is a chain of five different things, and it changes hands more often than any other skill's. Levels 1 to 42 belong to quests, or to an hour in the Chambers of Xeric thieving room if you would rather raid than talk to people. From 45 to 49 and again from 65 to 84 it belongs to blackjacking. From 49 to 65 stealing artefacts is quicker. From 84 it belongs to the Rogues' Castle chest, and from 91 Pyramid Plunder is the quickest thing available outside the Wilderness. Blackjacking stays viable all the way to 99 if you would rather not swap.

Blackjacking is the method with a real skill ceiling, so it deserves the detail. Lure a single bandit into an empty house where the other bandits cannot see him, knock him out, then pickpocket him twice while he is unconscious. The timing is correct when your experience drops arrive every two ticks. Trap him properly — knock him out, run away, come back and stand in front of him so he cannot walk through you — and he will not return to his spawn as long as you keep working. Ali the Dyer's house in the north of Pollnivneach is the standard spot for the bearded and unbearded bandits because it is tiny and has a ladder; a Menaphite Thug goes in the southern part of the house next to the bar.

What separates people who like blackjacking from people who bounce off it is what they do with a failed knockout. A missed knock-out makes the bandit aggressive, and robbing an awake bandit is how you eat a stun. The best answer is simply to knock him out again immediately, which is a reaction test. The reliable answer is to keep your inventory full of food so that the pickpocket attempt cannot actually take a coin pouch: the click only fires a dialogue prompt, and selecting it resets his aggression, after which you can knock him out at once even though you appear stunned. If he actually enters combat you cannot rob or knock him out at all — unequip the blackjack or switch weapons, attempt a knock-out to break him off, wait a few seconds, then re-equip.

Rogues' Castle is fast because the chest is worth 701.7 experience and respawns in about twenty seconds, and dangerous because it sits by the north wall of a castle in deep Wilderness multicombat that both player killers and Wilderness Slayer traffic pass through. Search for traps before every loot or you take damage instead, and have Protect from Melee up before you open it, because looting makes the rogues around you aggressive. The Chaos Elemental is a genuine hazard on the walk in if you are not taking the obelisk.

Pyramid Plunder is the fastest thing outside the Wilderness from 91, and it is a timed minigame rather than a grind, which means the method is a route rather than a rhythm. Loot the golden chest and every urn in the final room, take the golden chests on the way through, and pick up urns in the second-to-last room only if the clock allows. A charged pharaoh's sceptre teleporting you straight to the guardian mummy is what turns it from a pleasant activity into a fast one, and the golden artefacts you loot are what recharge it.

Blackjacking (Bearded Bandits etc.) is the historic high-XP click fest when done correctly.

Pyramid Plunder is a strong alternative with less “same tile forever” pain for many players.

Ardougne knights with rogue outfit are the sustainable long grind for a huge share of 99s.

Cheapest / Budget Approach

Thieving is one of the very few skills that needs no items at all to train, with three exceptions the wiki names explicitly: blackjacking, breaking into houses in Varlamore, and anything involving a lockpick. That makes the affordable route easy to define — it is the route where you never fail. Stall theft succeeds every time as long as you are not in the line of sight of the owner or a nearby guard, and a chest cannot stun you unless it is trapped and you skipped the trap check. No failures means no food, and no food means no bill.

In practice that is the bakery stall in East Ardougne from 5, the Hosidius fruit stalls from 25, the Aldarin villa chests from 36 with a lockpick and some energy potions, and the Dorgesh-Kaan rich chests from 78. The Sorceress's Garden runs alongside all of it from level 1, and it is close to free: the beer glasses you need can be found by searching the shelves in the Sorceress's house before you teleport in, and the only other tool is a pestle and mortar. What it costs is trips, and a lot of them — from 65, reaching 99 through the summer garden is 4,196 glasses of juice, which is 8,392 runs past the guardians.

The two spending decisions actually worth thinking about are food and necklaces. Blackjacking wants inventory-blocking food, which sounds expensive until you realise jugs of wine bought from Faisal at the Asp and Snake Bar in Pollnivneach do the job that Saradomin brews do, at the price of slightly lower rates and a slightly fiddlier drink. Dodgy necklaces cost you a quarter of your failed pickpockets and last ten charges each; if you are running a target you rarely fail, they are close to a waste, and if you are running one you fail often, they are the cheapest rate increase on the list.

Gloves of silence are the classic false economy here. They add five per cent success and are cheap to make at the Fancy Clothes Store in Varrock from two dark kebbit furs, and they can be restored to new condition with a fur and some thread at 64 Crafting rather than replaced. But they break after sixty-two failures counted from new, they need 54 Hunter to wear at all, and the Ardougne Diary perks override their bonus entirely — which means they are worthless inside Ardougne once the medium tier is done, and worthless everywhere once the hard tier is.

Thieving is often profitable — food is the main cost on failure-heavy methods.

Rogue outfit doubles many seed/loot quantities — prioritise Wilderness Rogues’ Castle pieces.

Do not buy expensive food if cheaper options keep you at the same XP.

AFK & Lower-Intensity Options

There is no genuinely unattended Thieving method, because the two-tick action rate and the coin pouch cap both punish walking away. What exists instead is a spread of methods that ask for less of you, and the best of them is stealing valuables in Civitas illa Fortis. A street urchin periodically distracts a wealthy citizen, and while the distraction lasts you pickpocket automatically for around twenty seconds with guaranteed success. Inside a house, valuables keep being looted automatically for about a minute per piece of furniture. The three-minute homeowner cycle gives the whole activity a metronome you can follow with half your attention, and world-hopping is how you trade that comfort back for speed.

Stealing artefacts is the option for people who want their hands busy on something else entirely. Because the smuggling run is walking rather than clicking, the wiki lists a whole set of things you can do in the gaps: fletching ammunition, casting High Level Alchemy, burning logs, cutting gems, making certain potions, and baking pies with Bake Pie. It is the only Thieving method that reliably pays two skills at a normal rate.

The Sorceress's Garden earns a mention for the same reason. A one-click traversal of the summer garden leaves a considerable amount of running time between actions, which you can either spend idle or spend zero-timing Magic or Fletching for a small loss to the juice rate — and the fruit picking quietly hands you a little passive Farming and Cooking experience regardless. Underwater Thieving on Fossil Island splits its output between Thieving and Agility, which makes it slow on the Thieving line and efficient across two, and it tends to be worth it consistently from 85 onwards.

For low-attention pickpocketing specifically, the answer at the very top of the skill is TzHaar-Hur. Their loot contains no coins, which removes the coin pouch interruption that defines every other pickpocketing method; a lured TzHaar-Hur can be robbed with repeated left-clicks, and the only remaining jobs are drinking a brew and replacing a dodgy necklace. It is less attention-demanding than the Knights of Ardougne by some distance, which is exactly why it needs a fire cape, ice gloves, the hard diary and the Thieving cape to be worth doing.

Thieving is rarely AFK. Knights are rhythm-based, not AFK.

If you need low intensity, pick methods with fewer failure animations even if XP dips.

Shadow of the Storm / early quests reduce the painful low levels.

The Profitable Route

The single most important fact about making money from this skill is that rogue equipment doubles your loot and does absolutely nothing to your experience. The full set guarantees double loot on every pickpocket, individual pieces give a chance of it, and the experience drops are identical either way. That one line is why the profit route and the fast route diverge as sharply as they do: the outfit comes out of the Rogues' Den wall safe at 50 Thieving, and the hours you spend getting it buy nothing at all if 99 is the only thing you want.

The profit targets themselves are mostly high-level and mostly narrow. Master Farmers yield ranarr and snapdragon seeds, and although they unlock at 38 the wiki is blunt that low levels give poor experience and poor returns because you fail so often — the real version of the method is 94 Thieving with the hard Ardougne Diary for guaranteed success, plus a Farming level, because seed rarity scales with Farming up to 85. Prifddinas elves drop enhanced crystal teleport seeds and need Song of the Elves. Vyres need Sins of the Father. TzHaar-Hur pay in tokkul and gems, and want a gem bag left open so the gems do not end up on the floor when your inventory fills.

The Varlamore route is the one that pays without asking for a high level. Valuables are handed in to Oriana, a gladiator rank from the Fortis Colosseum increases what she gives you for them, and the blessed bone statuettes that come with the loot chisel down into blessed bone shards for passive Prayer experience. Two important caveats: rogue equipment does not increase the valuables you get, so leave the set at home if that is all you are after — but it does double the house keys you steal, which halves the key-collection errand.

Two side incomes are easy to miss. Chests pay in items rather than coins: the Aldarin villa chests drop uncut gems, herb seeds, medium clue scrolls and blessed bone shards, and the Rogues' Den safes give gems as well. And several pickpocket targets are clue scroll sources — H.A.M. members and wealthy citizens drop easy clues fairly often, gnomes give mediums uncommonly, paladins give hards rarely, and heroes give elites very rarely. If you are already grinding one of those targets, the clue stream is free. For current values on any of it, the wiki's tables are the place to look rather than any figure printed here.

Equipment Progression

Read that table with one idea in mind: nothing in Thieving increases the experience you get per action. Every item on it either doubles your loot or reduces the cost of failing. That sounds like a limitation and it is actually the opposite — because a failure costs you eight ticks of dead time plus a chunk of your food, cutting your failure rate is functionally an experience upgrade, which is why the Thieving cape and the diary bonus matter more than anything you can put in your weapon slot.

The consequence is that the whole list has an expiry date. The dodgy necklace, Shadow Veil and the gloves of silence all pay out only on attempts you would have failed, so they become worthless the moment your target's success rate hits a hundred per cent. Work out where that happens for the target you are using before you buy in bulk: with the hard diary it is 95 for the Knights of Ardougne, guards and desert bandits, 94 for Master Farmers and rogues, 93 for warriors, and 85 for men and women.

One overlap trips up nearly everyone. The gloves of silence and the Ardougne Diary do not stack — the diary's ten per cent replaces the gloves' five, so from the medium tier onwards the gloves do nothing inside Ardougne and from the hard tier they do nothing anywhere. The dodgy necklace and Shadow Veil are a different mechanism entirely: they dodge the stun rather than improve the steal, so they keep working after the gloves have stopped, and they combine with each other because the veil rolls first and the necklace rolls only after the target has shouted.

Where to Train

Which Route Should You Actually Pick?

Start with the one question that actually forks the route: will you do a manual two-tick rhythm for hours. Blackjacking is the fastest thing available from 45 to 49 and again from 65 to 84, and it asks you to knock a bandit out, rob him twice while he is down, and handle a failed knockout without letting him into combat. If that description sounds like a game you want to play, get The Feud done and build the whole middle of your route on Pollnivneach. If it sounds like work, do not half-commit to it, because a badly executed blackjack loop is slower than the alternatives as well as more annoying.

If the answer is no, your route is stealing artefacts from 49 to 65 and the Knights of Ardougne from 55 onwards. That combination is slower than the Pollnivneach line and considerably more forgiving: the artefact run is walking rather than clicking, and a properly lured knight can be robbed without your mouse moving at all. Do the medium Ardougne Diary before you settle into the knights rather than after, because the ten per cent applies to every attempt you make from that point and the failures are what cost you food.

The next fork is whether you will enter the Wilderness. Rogues' Castle is the fastest experience in the skill from 84 and it is the only fast option carrying a PvP tax — the sensible version of it involves bringing nothing you value, checking for traps every single time, and having Protect from Melee active before you open the chest. If the answer is no, your ceiling is Pyramid Plunder from 91, which means the awkward 84-to-91 stretch is covered by whatever you were already doing: blackjacking, knights, vyres or the Varlamore houses.

Then ask whether your goal is actually the level. If what you want is ranarr and snapdragon seeds, the answer is not a training method at all — it is 94 Thieving, the hard Ardougne Diary and a Farming level, and no amount of choosing a better route gets you there sooner. If what you want is enhanced crystal teleport seeds, the answer is Song of the Elves. If what you want is a specific quest or diary tier, look up its exact Thieving requirement and stop at it, because a lot of this skill's value is delivered at 30, 49, 52, 72 and 91 rather than at 99.

Finally, check the constraint you are least likely to notice, which is your food. If you cannot comfortably fund the healing that failed pickpockets require, the correct route is the one where you do not fail: stalls, the Aldarin and Dorgesh-Kaan chests, the Sorceress's Garden. It is slower on paper and it is the only version of the plan that does not stall out halfway through a session when the brews run out.

Practical Tips That Actually Matter

• Ardougne diary medium makes knights dramatically better — do not skip it.
• Gloves of silence / dodgy necklaces change failure math on some methods.
• Lockpick and quest unlocks matter more than people admit.

Tools worth turning on:

• RuneLite's Menu Entry Swapper is the blackjacking essential: put Pickpocket on left-click for the unconscious bandit while Knock-Out stays on right-click, and with the camera set so the right-click menu opens under the cursor you can run the whole loop without moving the mouse.
• The in-game NPC 'Attack' options setting, set to Hidden — or the attack priority set to always right-click — turns Pickpocket into a left-click for most NPCs. Equipping a bow with no arrows is the belt-and-braces version if you are worried about attacking something by accident.
• Resizable mode with the inventory dragged over your target, using Alt-drag on the Classic or Modern layout. This is the zero-mouse-movement setup for the Knights of Ardougne: an F-key opens the inventory over the knight, one click empties the coin pouches, the same F-key closes it.
• Spellbook filters set to utility spells only, so re-casting Shadow Veil is another F-key and a click in the same spot rather than a hunt through three pages of the Arceuus book.
• A Watchdog experience-drop alert group, which is the tool that makes the Port Roberts stalls workable. The cycle is four thefts then two, and an overhead counter driven off the experience drop tells you when to move without you having to count.
• The Saradomin brew setting that disables automatic vial smashing, so a drink leaves the empty vial in your inventory and your inventory stays blocked while blackjacking.
• Camera zoom and angle discipline generally. Both of the top pickpocketing methods are built on the same idea — get the target and the interface into positions where the correct click never needs the mouse to travel.

Common Mistakes

Ironman Notes

Thieving occupies an odd position on an Ironman: it is one of the few skills that hands you raw materials other skills need, while simultaneously running a food bill that nothing else replaces. On the supply side it is genuinely valuable — Master Farmer ranarr and snapdragon seeds go straight into Farming and therefore into Herblore, the Aldarin villa chests drop herb seeds and blessed bone shards, and gems come out of Dorgesh-Kaan, the Rogues' Den safes and the TzHaar-Hur for Crafting. On the consumption side, every failed pickpocket is damage, and there is no shop that will sell you the healing.

That gives an iron a clear priority order that a main does not have. The rogue outfit is not optional here, because you cannot buy it and it doubles the loot on every profit method you will ever run — so the Rogues' Den at 50 is a scheduled stop rather than a detour. And the low-failure methods are worth more to you than their rates suggest, because a stall theft or an untrapped chest consumes nothing at all.

On an account with no Grand Exchange, Thieving is unusual in being a net supplier that also runs a real consumption bill. What it supplies is genuinely useful: Master Farmer ranarr and snapdragon seeds feed Farming and therefore Herblore, the Aldarin chests drop herb seeds and blessed bone shards, and the gems from Dorgesh-Kaan, the Rogues' Den safes and the TzHaar-Hur feed Crafting. What it consumes is food, in quantity, and that is the part an iron has to plan for rather than assume.

The practical route reflects that. Take the quest experience to 42, because it is the cheapest experience in the skill and several of those quests are ones you want anyway. Get the rogue outfit out of the Rogues' Den at 50, since you cannot buy it and it doubles loot on every profit method afterwards. Then decide honestly whether your food stock can support blackjacking; if it cannot, jugs of wine from Faisal's bar in Pollnivneach are bought locally and unnoted brews are not, and the stall and chest routes fail so rarely that they cost nothing at all. The Aldarin chests and Dorgesh-Kaan are the two places where an iron gets levels and stock in the same session.

Hardcore accounts should treat Rogues' Castle as off the table. The wiki's own advice for surviving it is to sit at deliberately low health and die to the rogues on purpose when a player killer appears, so that your loot lands in your gravestone rather than their inventory — a strategy that is entirely sensible on a normal iron and unthinkable on a hardcore one. Pyramid Plunder from 91 is the safe ceiling, and it also gives you the pharaoh's sceptre, which is a teleport an iron will actually use.

When Paid Training Makes Sense

The case for buying Thieving rests on what it is blocking. The cost of a gathering skill is hours rather than gold. Worth buying if those hours are the only thing between you and the content you actually log in for; not worth buying if you find the rhythm of it relaxing, which plenty of people genuinely do.

If you do order it, the thing to specify is the route as well as the level range: fastest and profit are different jobs on this skill, with different timelines and different supply bills for the same 99. Our Thieving page lists what we need from you, and the work is played rather than botted.

FAQ

Do I need The Feud to train Thieving properly?

You need it partially completed to wield a blackjack, and a blackjack is the only way to knock a bandit unconscious, so without it the whole Pollnivneach line from 45 to 84 is closed to you. It also happens to be the biggest early quest reward in the skill at 15,000 experience, and it only asks for 30 Thieving. If you skip it, your route becomes stealing artefacts from 49 and the Knights of Ardougne from 55.

Blackjacking or the Knights of Ardougne?

Blackjacking is faster and is a genuine manual skill — knock out, rob twice while he is down, recover cleanly from a missed knockout, and confirm your timing by watching for an experience drop every two ticks. The knights are slower and can be reduced to spam-clicking one spot on a lured target with almost no mouse movement, and with the medium diary you stop failing them entirely at 95. Choose on whether you want to be practising something or not.

How much food does Thieving actually need?

Enough that it belongs in your budget. For the Knights of Ardougne from 55 to 95 the wiki's figure is around sixteen thousand hitpoints of healing and roughly two hundred dodgy necklaces, with natural regeneration already accounted for. Blackjacking wants a specific kind of food rather than a large amount: inventory-blocking items like Saradomin brews, pies, curry or jugs of wine, because a full inventory is what stops you accidentally robbing a conscious bandit.

Do I have to go into the Wilderness for 99?

No. Rogues' Castle chests are the fastest experience from 84, but Pyramid Plunder is the fastest thing outside the Wilderness from 91, and blackjacking stays viable all the way to 99. The Varlamore houses, the Knights of Ardougne and the vyres all reach the cape as well. The Wilderness route buys speed and pays for it in risk, and the wiki's own mitigation is to die to the rogues on purpose rather than to a player killer.

What exactly does the Ardougne Diary give me?

The medium tier needs 38 Thieving and gives ten per cent higher pickpocket success inside Ardougne. The hard tier needs 72 and extends that bonus to every NPC in Gielinor. Coin pouch capacity rises with each tier as well: 56 at medium, 84 at hard, 140 at elite, which needs 82. The Ardougne cloak does not need to be equipped or even carried for any of it, and the bonus overrides the gloves of silence rather than adding to them.

Can I train something else at the same time?

Stealing artefacts is built for it, because the smuggling leg is walking rather than clicking — fletching ammunition, High Level Alchemy, burning logs, cutting gems, some potion making and Bake Pie all fit in the gaps. Underwater Thieving on Fossil Island trains Thieving and Agility together. A one-click traversal of the Sorceress's summer garden leaves running time you can put into Magic or Fletching for a small loss to the juice rate.

Why did my Thieving level just drop?

Picking locks carries a random chance of numbing your fingers, which is a temporary debuff to the skill. It wears off at roughly a minute per point lost, so on a lockpicking method like the Aldarin chests or Dorgesh-Kaan it is a mild interruption rather than a problem.

Where does Rocky come from?

The Thieving pet can come from stealing from stalls, pickpocketing NPCs, picking fruit in the Sorceress's Garden, and looting the grand gold chests in Pyramid Plunder. The chance depends on your level and on what you are stealing from, so it is a reason to prefer a method you were already going to use rather than a reason to change methods.

Which method has the best rates right now?

We deliberately do not print rates, because they are revised and because the answer is a table rather than a name — the wiki keeps per-level figures for blackjacking, stealing artefacts, the knights, Pyramid Plunder, stealing valuables and the Port Roberts stalls. What does not move is the shape of the answer: quests to 42, blackjacking or artefacts through the middle, Rogues' Castle from 84 if you accept the risk, Pyramid Plunder from 91 if you do not.

Final Takeaway

The thread running through all of this is that Thieving prices failure. Every other gathering skill fails quietly and costs you a tick; here a failure costs damage, nine ticks of being unable to move and eight of being unable to steal, which is why every item in the equipment list is either 'fail less' or 'get hit less', and why the skill becomes noticeably easier the moment your fail rate reaches zero rather than the moment you unlock something new.

So plan around two levels rather than one. The first is wherever your chosen target stops failing you — 95 for the Knights of Ardougne, 94 for Master Farmers, 85 for men and women — because that is where the food and the necklaces stop mattering. The second is 72, for the hard Ardougne Diary, because completing it brings the first date forward for every target at once. Everything else in the route is a preference about whether you would rather practise a two-tick knockout, walk artefacts across a bridge, or accept a PvP tax at a chest in the deep Wilderness.

If the honest answer is that you want the levels for Pyramid Plunder, the diary tier or a quest requirement, and not a few hundred thousand knockout cycles to get them, our hand-played Thieving training will run whichever band you name — say up front whether you want the blackjacking route or the low-failure stall and chest route, because they finish at very different times and consume very different amounts of food.

Browse Thieving training, more skill guides, or the full blog for related progression help.